top of page

Can you walk two karate paths at once?

  • Writer: OGKK Australia
    OGKK Australia
  • 2 days ago
  • 2 min read

I follow this Uechi-ryu group on social media based in Spain. Mostly because of the vibe, maybe the lighting, the overall airiness… and yeah, don't mind the dojo floors either. My own karate and kobudo sensei have even visited the place to run seminars, and you can add several kiai stars from the Olympics too.


Uechi Ryu - Shubukan Spain (Every granny and their long lost kid seem to have a dojo called Shubukan...)
Uechi Ryu - Shubukan Spain (Every granny and their long lost kid seem to have a dojo called Shubukan...)

So the other day, I noticed something that made me stop, squint, and reread. The group were off to Okinawa to train both Goju-ryu and Uechi-ryu. What the.....? Is that actually possible? NOTE: This is not a criticism but is it possible to learn both systems at the same time, especially when you’re not yet deeply adept in either? I’m not saying the sensei is incompetent, but from a student’s point of view. It raises the question - Wouldn’t it mess with the mind? A little information overload?

Have a sticky beak at their page to satisfy all your Goju & Uechi-ryu curiosity.
Have a sticky beak at their page to satisfy all your Goju & Uechi-ryu curiosity.

Goju-ryu and Uechi-ryu aren’t just two flavours of the same pint of grog. They have different training emphases, different rhythms, and very different breathing sounds - the latter involving noises I can’t seriously imagine making without pissing myself. Yes, there are overlaps, shared roots, and common sources. But for a novice learning both at once, wouldn’t this blur those nice, clean karate concepts, like an Aussie learning Japanese and somehow delivering it confidently in a thick Indian accent?


That said, I completely understand the opposite argument. After a substantial amount of time in either Okinawan Goju or Uechi-ryu, curiosity feels almost inevitable. You start noticing similarities & differences. You may begin to wonder where they cross paths, where they diverge, and what each system might reveal about the other. At that point, stepping into the “other” style probably isn’t about mindless kata collecting anymore (like many foreigners seems to love doing), but about deepening understanding.


Like always, I don’t even know what I’m saying here half the time haha. I’m not complaining, nor am I criticising anyone. I’m just thinking out loud.......Personally, the thought of me learning Uechi-ryu on top of my Goju-ryu… hmmm. It would be interesting. Possibly confusing, potentially very humbling and maybe deeply rewarding. If I ever had the chance, I’d be happy, willing, and open to explore it. Not to replace what I already train, and definitely not to rush the process, but to see things from another angle. To feel familiar movements through a different lens. To let one system ask questions the other never thought to ask.

 
 
 

Comments


Join our mailing list

bottom of page